dismissed
EB-3
dismissed EB-3 Case: Unknown
Decision Summary
The appeal was dismissed because it was not filed within the required 33-day period following the director's decision. The initial motion was received 43 days after the decision was issued, and subsequent appeals were also untimely, leading the AAO to reject them on procedural grounds.
Criteria Discussed
Timeliness Of Appeal
Sign up free to download the original PDF
Downloaded the case? Use it in your next draft →View Full Decision Text
Uv. s. Citizenship
and Immigration
Date:
,:la1 pursuant
203(b)(3) {sf the Irnrriigrafiun and .Nationality Act, 8 U.S.C. 3 1 153jb)(3)
?-his is the decision ofthe ,~ldrnii~istr.at!ire Appeals Office in your case. AIi ~LPCL~:'T~C~I~S have bee11 retur-fled to
the oirice that t.rriginal8y decided your case. rAiriy further inquirg, rnrrst be made ru that office.
robe:^ P. Wfe~~awl. C.:hief
Admil- strit; ,4{3]3eals Office
XBXSCBISSION: Tile Director, Vermotrt Service Center, defiied fhc' immig-rant visa petition on August 11.
2004. The petitioner appealed the directi?s's decision. 'b'he director dismissed the hfotion co
lteopen!'Reco,zsic~r'r~ as ~t, was rmt slilmitted witiiin 33 days of the date of ihe director's decision dakd August
I I, 2004. The matter is now bef'ctre the Admii:!stsative i'.ppeals Crilke (ALZC)) on appeals. T11.e prior decismn
ofthe ifirector dated Augiis? 1 1,2004, is aikned. The appeals are rqjected.
In order to properly file an appeal, the regulation at li: C.F.R. tj i03..3(aj(?)(i) provides that the agected party
nzust iiie the compicte appeal within 30 days i?i'after sei-vice of the unhivol-able decisisj-r. Tffhe decision was
txai'ied, the appeal must be filed within 33 dzys. Se:3 8 C.F.M. 4 1133.5a(b).
'X'I-re record indicaies t1zat -the d-irecior issued the decision on August 11, 2004. The director properly gave
notice to the petitiorrer that ;I had 33 days to file the appeal. Goutlsel submitted documents to the dirc~t~r OM
Septen-tbes 10, 2004. hi:hc)ugh xhc cover !eiTer indicated tiiai a Form 1-290B was included wit11 an aff'fidavii
.from the petitioner itrld a letter fiorr: an accountant, no Fujm 1-290B ivas inchidcd. 'ii'he director returned the
documents and filling fee nnd stated, "If you vjrsh the attached letter be cisnsidered ns ynizr h4olio1-t to
reopen/Mecorrsicier piease aanotate tf-re letter, or a statement tl-tat courrsel desired that the docr~nzenl submittal
be considered as a Motion to Keaper~Recor?,sider," Subsequently counsel by letter dated Septeinher 23, 2004,
mil received 4x1 that date, sent docun:.ents with an unsigned Form I-290B t~sv dated Sepcenlber [no day date
given] 21904 and wli'rl a cover letter indicat'i~g thai ti-re subtrl:8a1 be consrclered as a Mcstion to
Meopen!'Keconsider.
Citi;.enshlp and Immigration Services (CIS) receivrd the niutio1-r to reopen on Seyten-her 23. 2004, G dzys
afier the decisiorr was issuesl. Accordingly, it was unt~rtlely Cilelt.
Subsequently co~inssj filed t:.vi> Motions to FE-zopei; the direcior's decisior: dated A~~ugust I 1, 2004 as recervecl
I)., ccernber .. 14,2004, r,nd April 22, 3005. 'The iast appeal was received 255 dnys after the decisiori was issued.
Hot11 appeals ivere iaztimely filed.
The regu1;rtiol-t at 8 C.F.K.
103.3(a)(2)(v)(Bi(L) states that, if an untimely appeal meets the req~iiren~ents oFa
rnatiol-i to reupen or 3 .motion to reconsider, the appeal inust be treated as a 1-notion: arid n decision Exist be
rnacie on the merits of the case. The oft-;cia1 hav~ng jurisdiction over a motion is the official whra made the
last dec~sion in the prcjceedi~~g, in this case the sexvice center director. See X C.F.R. 6 IOi.S(a){l)(ii). '?'he
director declined to treai the iaie appeal as a n:otion and fbrvjarded tile matler to tile A.40.
.As the zp-ppeals :vcre urztinic?:y filed, the appeals must be rejected.
ORDER: 7-he appealsre rejected. Avoid the mistakes that led to this denial
MeritDraft learns from dismissed cases so your petition avoids the same pitfalls. Get arguments built on winning precedents.
Avoid This in My Petition →No credit card required. Generate your first petition draft in minutes.