H-1B Dismissed — Oil And Gas (2020): the record contained significant inconsistencies regarding

Decision Summary

The appeal was dismissed because the record contained significant inconsistencies regarding the proffered position's duties and level of responsibility. The petitioner described the role as having supervisory and leadership functions, yet also claimed the beneficiary would be constantly supervised and would not act independently. These contradictions, along with work samples suggesting autonomy, precluded a determination that the position qualified as a specialty occupation requiring a bachelor's degree in a specific field.

Criteria Discussed

Sign up free to download the original PDF