dismissed
EB-1A
dismissed EB-1A Case: Wrestling
Decision Summary
The appeal was rejected because it was improperly filed as an appeal of a prior AAO decision. The AAO does not have jurisdiction to adjudicate appeals of its own decisions; the petitioner should have filed a motion to reconsider or a motion to reopen instead.
Criteria Discussed
Jurisdiction Motion To Reconsider Motion To Reopen Appeal Procedure
Sign up free to download the original PDF
Downloaded the case? Use it in your next draft →View Full Decision Text
U.S.Departmentof HomelandSecurity U.S.CitizenshipandImmigrationServices AdministrativeAppealsOffice (AAO) 20MassachusettsAve.,N.W.,MS2090 . e Washington,DC 20529-2090 U.S.Citizenship and Immigration Services PUBLICCOPY DATE: APR 0 2 2012 OFFICE:TEXAS SERVICECENTER IN RE: Petitioner: Beneficiary: PETITION: ImmigrantPetitionfor Alien WorkerasanAlien of ExtraordinaryAbility Pursuantto Section 203(b)(1)(A)of theImmigrationandNationalityAct,8 U.S.C.ยง 1153(b)(1)(A) ON BEHALF OF PETITIONER: INSTRUCTIONS: Enclosedpleasefind thedecisionof theAdministrativeAppealsOffice(AAO) in yourcase.All of thedocuments relatedtothismatterhavebeenreturnedto theofficethatoriginallydecidedyourcase.Pleasebeadvisedthatany further inquiry that you might haveconcerningyour casemust be madeto that office. If you believethe law was inappropriatelyappliedby us in reachingour decision,or you haveadditional informationthatyou wishto haveconsidered,you mayfile a motionto reconsideror a motionto reopen.The specificrequirementsfor filing sucharequestcanbefoundat8 C.F.R.ยง 103.5.All motionsmustbesubmittedto the office that originally decidedyour caseby filing a Form I-290B, Notice of Appealor Motion, with a fee of $630. Pleasebe awarethat 8 C.F.R. ยง 103.5(a)(1)(i) requiresthat any motion must be filed within 30 daysof the decisionthatthemotionseekstoreconsiderorreopen. Thankyou, PerryRhew Chief,AdministrativeAppealsOffice www.uscis.gov Page2 DISCUSSION: Thedirector,TexasServiceCenter,deniedtheemployment-basedimmigrantvisapetition onNovember10,2009.TheAdministrativeAppealsOffice(AAO) dismissedthepetitioner'sappealof the director'sadversedecisionOnMay9,2011. OnJune10,2011,thepetitionerfiled asecondappealwith the AAO. Theappealwill berejected. Thepetitioner,who is alsothebeneficiary,seeksclassificationasan"alienof extraordinaryability" in the athletics,specifically,asa wrestler,pursuantto section203(b)(1)(A)of theImmigrationandNationality Act (theAct or INA), 8 U.S.C.ยง 1153(b)(1)(A). OnMay 9, 2011,theAAO affirmedthedirector'sNovember10,2009adversedecisionanddismissedthe petitioner'sappeal. In its decision,the AAO instructedthe petitionerthatif he believesthat the AAO appliedthelaw inappropriatelyin reachingthedecision,or if hehasadditionalinformationthathewishes theAAO to consider,he"mayfile a motionto reconsideror a motionto reopen."Insteadof filing sucha motion,on June10,2011,thepetitionerfiled a secondNoticeof Appealor Motion,FormI-290B. On pages1 and2 of theFormI-290B,counselindicatedthatheis filing anappealof theAAO's May 9, 2011 decision.1TheAAO, however,doesnothavejurisdictionoveranappealof itsowndecision. The authorityto adjudicateappealsis delegatedto the AAO by the Secretaryof the Departmentof HomelandSecurity(DHS)pursuantto theauthorityvestedin him or herthroughtheHomelandSecurity Act of 2002,Pub.L. 107-296.SeeDHSDelegationNumber0150.1(effectiveMarch 1,2003);8 C.F.R.ยง 2.1 (2003). The AAO exercisesappellatejurisdiction over the matters describedat 8 C.F.R. ยง 103.1(f)(3)(iii)(2003).Accordingly,theappealisnotproperlywithin theAAO'sjurisdiction. TheAAO doesnothavejurisdictionovertheinstantappeal,whichisanappealof theAAO's owndecision. Accordingly,theappealmustberejected,asit wasnotproperlyfiled. See8 C.F.R.ยง 103.3(a)(2)(v)(A)(1). ORDER: Theappealisrejected. Althoughcounsel'sbrief accompanyingtheJune10,2011FormI-290B is entitled"Motion to Reconsider,"his FormI- 290Bclearlyindicatesthatheintendedto file anappeal.
Avoid the mistakes that led to this denial
MeritDraft learns from dismissed cases so your petition avoids the same pitfalls. Get arguments built on winning precedents.
Avoid This in My Petition →No credit card required. Generate your first petition draft in minutes.